Alright, I know maybe one or two of you are wondering what I decided after writing
this post.
Well, I took all your suggestions (thankyouVERYmuch), did a little research...OK a LOT of research, and one name kept popping up, kinda like this:
BECO (
beco...
beco..
beco)
Everywhere I turned, this is what I kept hearing:
"I bought an X, but I WANT a Beco."
"The Beco wasn't out when I had little kids, but I TOTALLY would have wanted one."
"The Beco cost too much money, so I didn't get it, but MAN I wanted to."
Yeah. I hear ya on that last one. So I know it's like, none of your business how I spend my money, but I have this thing that makes me HAVE to justify myself even to perfect strangers when I splurge on something ("really, waitress, I NEVER order the filet mignon, but I just got a raise and my dog died and my doctor told me I'm anemic..."). So here's my justification.
I cheap out on just about everything. The only things we've bought new for this baby were some of his clothes. OK, and his carseat. Really, I'm wracking my brain here and...I'm pretty sure that's an accurate statement. OH! and a $20 high chair. And I would have bought one of these used but such a thing does not exist. They are really new, and if you have one, you aren't selling it. Also, I have a bad back. Really, ask my chiropractor. I'll get you signed note if you want. And I'm totally going to get a ton of use out of this thing, since I love carrying my baby. And I'll have more babies that will use it. I'll have a dozen more if it will help me justify this! Really! I NEEDED IT! AND.....
I TOTALLY BOUGHT A BECO!! There. I said it.
Now. Deciding to buy a Beco is only the first step, because they have about one gazillion different designs. I'm not even exaggerating. So the key for us was finding one that was cute, and that neither one of us would be embarrassed wearing. Well that narrowed Mike's options by about 93%.
And I know one reader in particular may actually hate me when she reads this, but.... this is the one we got:

I know. I know! When it came down to it, it really was the cutest, gender-neutral option.
So Flurg and I went for a little stroll around the block this evening to try it out. While walking, we discussed the ergonomic shape, the back support and straps, the distribution of weight, ease of use, ability to switch from front to back, etc. and etc. and we came to a consensus, me and Flurg: we totally love it.
I'm feeling much more relaxed about traveling now that I have a kick-A baby carrier. Still a little worried about what position he'll be able to sleep in (and briefly considered buying a doggie bed, but it was a bit too large for my lap), but a lot less stressed about the whole thing.
Thank you all for your suggestions. You're totally judging me right now, aren't you. I KNEW it!